Bray to check AR's decision

SANZAR referees' boss Lyndon Bray has said that the error that initiated a Crusaders try against the Hurricanes in their 26-26 draw on Friday will be discussed at an official level.

An SANZAR review of officiating incidents in the match will be held on Tuesday and it appears assistant referee Garratt Williamson will be the man in the spotlight.

The Dominion Post reports that Bray on Sunday reiterated his support for referee Jonathan Kaplan's TMO-assisted decision to award hooker Ti'i Paulo a last-minute try.

But Bray said that the quick throw-in that initiated the movement leading to the Crusaders second try, scored by left wing Zac Guildford, was incorrect.

"The lineout from a decision point of view that was clearly wrong," Bray said.

"Unfortunately, with the ball over the touchline, the main responsibility with what happens to that ball rests with the assistant referee.

"As a referee you can't reasonably be expected to pick that up when you are still dealing with things out on the field.

"It's generally accepted that the assistant referee's role once it's out, is to know what happens to it. In that sense Garratt's got to cop that on the chin and we'll discuss that with him.

"In terms of what action we might decide to take, that won't happen until Tuesday, which is our normal debrief where we decide what we will do about it."

Williamson allowed Crusaders halfback Andy Ellis to take a quick throw-in despite the ball being touched by Hurricanes players and replacements.

Williamson has already been involved in controversy this season, with Blues head coach Pat Lam criticising his officiating after the Blues controversial defeat to the Waratahs in Sydney on March 27.

But the Dominion Post reports that Bray said that overall he remained pleased with his team of referees this season and the TMO process despite some controversies.

Though he agreed the Hurricanes had not been lucky in recent weeks, Bray said referees' calls worked both ways, citing Jeremy Thrush's first-half try as an example.

"My gut feeling is there was obstruction. Jonathan's made it clear what he thinks and that is that the Crusaders player ran into the Hurricanes player and could have avoided it. We'll review that too.

"It's swings and roundabouts. It's like anything in sport though, the closer you are to the line the more at risk you are to decisions that go against you costing you potential points or games and that's just reality."




Pro Legoete, one of South Africa's top referees, will be back at Newlands this weekend for the second weekend in a row. In the meantime he is also answering readers' questions.

READ THE LATEST HERE!

The Super 14 is rattling on, sometimes surprisingly, sometimes predictably, often entertainingly, sometimes controversially. We give some stats of the seventh round and some totals of who did what right and wrong over the seven rounds.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

(c) AFP
SANZAR has announced the match official for Weeks 6-8. They include the return of Stuart Dickinson and Nathan Pearce from injury and relatively new men in Jaco Peyper, Jonathon White and Garratt Williamson.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

The 2010 Six Nations is over and France have the Grand Slam they deserved. We have some statistics, with totals, which will tell you about the teams - who scored the most tries and who conceded the most penalties; that sort of thing.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

Interested in becoming a referee? It’s never been easier. Fill in the Recruitment form below to find out more.

Full Name:
Location:
Address:
Email:
Contact:
Check out In-touch, South Africa’s national referee newsletter, to stay up-to-date with events affecting the whistle.

› In-touch Apr09- EMAIL

› In-touch Ed2 email

› In-Touch Edition 3- EMAIL

› Intouch_Vol 4 2008

› Intouch Vol 5 2008

› Intouch Vol 6 2008

Want a copy of the latest IRB-approved law book? (R50 incl. VAT and postage).

Full Name:
Location:
Address:
Email:
Contact:
Keep yourself updated by following us through our RSS Feed.