Clip 9 - 24 January 2012

Penalty try.

Northampton Saints put the ball into a scrum five metres from the Munster line. They win the ball, hold it at No.8 and shove Munster back quickly towards the goal-line.

The ball does not reach the goal-line because Peter O'Mahony (7) of Munster puts a foot in and kicks the ball away.

If it is still a scrum and the ball is under Roger Wilson's feet, then O'Mahony infringed. He did it deliberately. If he had not infringed it is almost certain that Northampton would have scored. That makes the penalty try a clear and obvious decision.

Should not a warning precede a penalty try? After all this had not occurred previously in the match.

No. A penalty try is for a one-off, stand-alone situation. It is not a punishment for an accumulation of infringements?

Should the referee have sent O'Mahony to the sin bin?

According to law, he should have.

Law 10.2 UNFAIR PLAY
(a)  Intentionally Offending. A player must not intentionally infringe any Law of the Game, or play unfairly. The player who intentionally offends must be either admonished, or cautioned that a send off will result if the offence or a similar offence is committed, or sent off. Sanction: Penalty kick
A penalty try must be awarded if the offence prevents a try that would probably otherwise have been scored. A player who prevents a try being scored through foul play must either be cautioned and temporarily suspended or sent off.




Three questions for Stuart Berry to answer. One disagrees with an IRB clarification, another disagrees with Stuart's previous answer and a third of practical application.

READ THE LATEST HERE!

It's a big weekend in Europe this coming weekend as it is the final round of the pool matches in the Heineken Cup and the Amlin Challenge Cup. The next step after this is the quarterfinals.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

A forward pass seems such a basic part of rugby football's laws. Missing a forward pass can bring great scorn onto the head of a referee. It is seen as simple law, easy to apply.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

Rasta Rashivenga refereed the first three rounds of the International Rugby Board's Sevens this year - in Gold Coast, Dubai and then Port Elizabeth. This is the third account of the South African's rugby Odyssey.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

Interested in becoming a referee? It’s never been easier. Fill in the Recruitment form below to find out more.

Full Name:
Location:
Address:
Email:
Contact:
Check out In-touch, South Africa’s national referee newsletter, to stay up-to-date with events affecting the whistle.

› In-Touch Edition 2

› In- Touch Edition 1

› In- touch Apr09- EMAIL

› In-touch Ed2 email

› In- Touch Edition 3- EMAIL

› Intouch_Vol 4 2008

› Intouch Vol 5 2008

› Intouch Vol 6 2008

Want a copy of the latest IRB-approved law book? (R50 incl. VAT and postage).

Full Name:
Location:
Address:
Email:
Contact:
Keep yourself updated by following us through our RSS Feed.