Clip 9 - 1 September

Is there advantage in in-goal?

Five metres from the Pumas' line, the Blue Bulls tap a penalty, get the ball back and pass to the left where Dewald Potgieter knocks the ball forward and into the Pumas' in-goal where Elgar Watts of the Pumas swoops on the ball and moves to his left, presumably to kick clear.

The referee blows his whistle and orders a scrum for the knock-on.

There was a knock-on and the sanction for it is a scrum.

The Pumas then had to win the ball from the scrum and get it back to Watts for him to kick for touch.

This does not make sense. He already had the ball and probably had more room to kick for touch than he would have from a scrum.

Advantage in a situation like this certainly applies and it would have been wiser to wait to see what Watts did with the ball he had from the knock-on.




(c) Gallo
We have just one question this time, because it seemed appropriate that André Watson, South Africa's boss of referees, answer it.

READ THE LATEST HERE!

At the half-way mark in the Currie Cup, André Watson, South Africa's referees boss, has sent out an interim report to his referees on their Currie Cup performances.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

(c) Getty
The Tri-Nations reaches its penultimate match, the Women's World Cup reaches its final round, England's Premiership and the Magners League. And referees are coming and going all over the place.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

What a grand occasion - South Africa vs New Zealand at the FNB Stadium in Johannesburg on Saturday afternoon. We give some statistics, a boring thing to do of such an exciting occasion.
READ THE LATEST HERE!

Interested in becoming a referee? It’s never been easier. Fill in the Recruitment form below to find out more.

Full Name:
Location:
Address:
Email:
Contact:
Check out In-touch, South Africa’s national referee newsletter, to stay up-to-date with events affecting the whistle.

› In-Touch Edition 1

› In-touch Apr09- EMAIL

› In-touch Ed2 email

› In-Touch Edition 3- EMAIL

› Intouch_Vol 4 2008

› Intouch Vol 5 2008

› Intouch Vol 6 2008

Want a copy of the latest IRB-approved law book? (R50 incl. VAT and postage).

Full Name:
Location:
Address:
Email:
Contact:
Keep yourself updated by following us through our RSS Feed.